

The latest notion to emerge from the discussions at ProjectAlberta.com is for the Alberta Alliance and the Separation Party of Alberta to join into one party. The thinking is that this would combine the independence movement behind a single party on the provincial scene, and thus become a solid force for the movement.
At first glance, this idea seems logical. Many Albertans who are believers of Alberta independence tend to support both parties to some degree. The two parties have some similar policies and ideas, and draw support from the same pool of voters. When you start to think about what would need to be done for this to happen, roadblocks appear all over the plan. From the Alliance perspective, their stated position is to give Canada one more chance - in the form of a sort of declaration of gripes. If the demands listed are not met by the federal government, then the party would, so they claim, introduce a more independent route that would lead to a referendum on independence. The positive spin on this plan is the impression would be given that Alberta is truely trying 'one last time' to get along, only to be rejected (kicked out?) by the big, bad federal monolith. Critics could play the obvious negative image, however: too similar to the Quebec game of blackmail and threats in the hopes of gifts from Ottawa. They might question the legitimacy of such an attempt by an Alliance government, given the fact that their are so many self-proclaimed separatists in the ranks. They will ask: are we really sincere in the offer of an olive branch to Canada? Or are we going through the motions with our minds already made up? The idea could easily be reduced to looking comical in the eyes of the Canadian public.
From the SPA side, we have a party that has failed in capitalizing on the current wave of separatism in Alberta. The leader, while calling himself 'intrim', refuses to open up the party to new blood. A top-down party can only serve those at the top. Bickering over changes to the party constitution as well as poorly planned public events have hindered members ability to focus on what is important, which is the impending doom of the NEP jr. That one policy will be enough to break the proverbial back of Albertans. A strong SPA could be the first party to claim to be the only one who will protect Alberta from the federal government, a sentiment that will not be lost on the people.
The solution sounds simple, but is far from being possible. The Alliance would have to change the position regarding separation. They would have to be open to a referendum upon forming the government. The SPA would have to open up to some policies that some members might not agree with. A leadership race would be vital. Whispers of a certain Mr. Harper returning home are fantasy (but a good one). A well-known leader would go a long way to uniting the new party as well as for credibility, but the chances of Harper making that career move are slim and none.
The advantages of a merger would be the increased size of support as well as resources. Our message would have to be taken more seriously on the national stage. Compromise would be the way for the hypothetical uniting of the movement. Compromise, and an act of God. Sphere: Related Content



















